Skip to main content

Troublemakers

     In the preface and introduction of Troublemakers, it talks about how schools often prioritize control rather than giving students freedom. Instead of valuing every individual, students are taught that some lives matter more than others. What we really need is to teach respect for all lives. Children shouldn't be punished or silenced for expressing themselves, as is often the case when they are reprimanded for not following the rules. Students miss out on valueable learning time when they are sent out of the classroom.


    Troublemakers is about four students who are labeled as “troublemakers” by their teachers, Instead of punishing these students, the Shalaby argues that we should listen to them, as they have valuable lessons to share. Teachers are trained to silence disruptive students. During my younger years of school, I was a very hyper and talkative child who was often reprimanded by my teachers for being disruptive. I also struggle with ADHD, which was a significant contributer to my behavior. I constantly had to sit out during recess for my behavior and publicly chastised in front of my peers. I found these to be very embarrasing and had a hard time with my peers because I was seen as "annoying". Even though my report cards always showed me doing well in my acadmeics, I always recieved comments of being "too chatty". This led me to become much more reserved in school and I conformed to being a quiet student. I have been lucky to have a few meaningful teachers who taught in ways that brought me out of my shell again and made me interested in learning. Teachers are the core of our education and have such a big impact on shaping the people we become. It's important for them to use compassion rather than discipline as you never know what a student is going through. 


Comments

  1. Edward smithMarch 3, 2025 at 11:20 AM

    Hi Ashely. You mentioned how some teachers publicly chastised you about being disruptive. I was one of those kids in school too. It made think that possibly some teachers who have been in the field for a while, or new teachers, may have forgotten how students can feel in situations like these and how it can negatively affect them.

    ReplyDelete
  2. MakenaMarch 17, 2025 at 11:50 AM

    Hi Ashley! Even at Webster Avenue I saw kids having to sit outside their classrooms and after reading Troublemakers I was like wow this still really does happen. I see kids in my class get remanded all day for talking. They are 5. This teacher is teaching them to be quiet and not have opinions. She also singles out people all day and the kids are scared of her. This is not how teaching should be.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Introduction

Hi! My name is Ashley Loiselle and I am a Junior at Rhode Island College. I am majoring in Early Childhood Education. I plan to open my own daycare in the future with my best friend. I completed my freshman year of college at the University of Rhode Island and decided to transfer for my sophmore year to RIC. Not only did I change schools, I also changed majors. Originally I thought the medical field was something I wanted to do but after working with young children the past few years, I know that is what I would like to do in the future. I love hanging out with my friends and spending time with my family. I like to go on hikes, bake and cook, and am a big movie watcher. 
Post a Comment
Read more

Finn

 Patrick Finn’s  Literacy with an Attitude  connects with Alfie Kohn’s article  What to Look for in a Classroom . Both authors talk about how schools often focus too much on control and order instead of helping students become active, thoughtful learners. Finn explains that working-class students often receive a basic kind of education that teaches them to follow directions and stay in line. He calls this “functional literacy.” On the other hand, students from wealthier backgrounds are given “powerful literacy,” which helps them ask questions, speak up, and become leaders. This idea connects to Kohn’s writing because Kohn also believes that good classrooms are not about quiet students doing worksheets. He wants schools to focus on group work, student choice, and learning that matters. In both texts, the authors agree that schools need to give all students the chance to grow, think, and participate, not just obey. They also both point out that teachers have a big role...
Post a Comment
Read more

Kohn

  Alfie Kohn’s article “What to Look for in a Classroom” made me think about what kind of classroom I want as a future teacher. He explains that learning should be meaningful and active, not just quiet students listening to a teacher talk. That idea reminded me of some of my past classes, where I felt bored and uninterested because we only followed directions, completed worksheets, and only listened to the teacher speak. In other classes, the teacher encouraged us to ask questions, share our ideas, and collabarate with one another. I remember feeling more comfortable to speak up and share my ideas than in classes that were teacher focused. Kohn’s ideas about student choice, collaboration, and respect feel important to me because that's when real learning occurs. I believe students need to feel like their thoughts and voices matter in order to grow and build confidence. If classrooms only focus on rules and control, students might stop caring about what they are learning. ...
Post a Comment
Read more